đ¤ Can a neural network come up with genuinely good creative?
Spoiler: yes.
Just not the way youâre hoping.
And certainly not on the first try.
AI is not a magical creative producer.
It wonât say:
âLetâs have the hero turn into a zombie every time they lose and then seek revenge on the whole cityâin an arcade style. Trust me, itâll work, cross my heart! I can even show you the future metrics.â
Instead itâll offer something like:
âHero loses â hero levels up â hero wins.â
(Then repeat that 17 times in slightly different words.)
And somewhere in that repetition a seed may appear.
Not an insight, but a hint of one.
If you know the context, youâll spot it.
đĄ What AI definitely can do
- Toss out dozens of concepts to match a brief.
- Suggest surprising mashâupsâsoâcalled chimeras or Frankensteins.
- Recall an old pattern thatâs suddenly relevant again.
- Adapt an idea for another audience, style, or platform.
- Generate references and propose interesting visuals.
(Thatâs not its full repertoire, but itâs the core.)
So it can add fuel to your thinkingâjust not build the whole rocket.
It doesnât know what currently âlandsâ with your audience.
It canât feel that âthis no longer gets clicks, but that really grabs.â
For now, thatâs still your job.
đ Where it truly helps
âď¸ When youâre stuck and need a kickâstart.
âď¸ For quickly sketching material for a brainstorm.
âď¸ To get a fresh angle on a boring product.
âď¸ As a rapidâfire âwhat ifâŚâ generator.
đ Where it falls apart
âď¸ Tone of voiceâŻââŻmixes vibes, sounds offâkey.
âď¸ EmpathyâŻââŻdoesnât feel the audienceâs pain or desire.
âď¸ DepthâŻââŻno motivation, no buildâup, just a naked idea.
đŻ How I use it
I donât ask âmake a creative.â
I say:
âSuggest 10 variants where the character levels up through failureâŻââŻbut make sure none of them copy existing trends.â
Plenty of answers arrive.
Nine go straight to the bin.
One might contain something interesting.
Not a finished product, but a starting point.
(Sometimes it spits out 100 ideas and none are useful.)
From there you flesh out the mechanics, visuals, conflict, pacing.
Itâs as if an assistant dumped their raw thoughts, and you spin them up.
AI does come up with wild mechanic combos now and thenâplus mountains of junkâso you still have to sift and polish.
đ§ The big upside
AI never gets tired and isnât afraid of sounding stupid.
Thatâs a superpower during idea generation:
sometimes a concept that sounds absurd at first, after a few iterations turns into âwait, that actually works.â
đť And the obvious downside
AI doesnât know what âworksâ means.
It just combines. You make the final calls.
đŻ Bottom line
AI is like a junior creative on steroids:
fast, obedient, tireless, never arguesâ
but lacking context and real insight into what hooks people.
(No offense to all juniors đ
)
Itâll spit out dozens of ideas, but it doesnât track trends, read market signals, or offer expertise.
It just mixes ingredients.
And you decide whatâs worth cookingâand what goes straight in the trash.